How Mental Illness is Misrepresented in the Media | Wellness | US News

mental disability articles

Mental Disabilities / October 27, 2022

Photo Credit Roman Muradov

TWO months ago, the British Psychological Society released a remarkable document entitled “Understanding Psychosis and Schizophrenia.” Its authors say that hearing voices and feeling paranoid are common experiences, and are often a reaction to trauma, abuse or deprivation: “Calling them symptoms of mental illness, psychosis or schizophrenia is only one way of thinking about them, with advantages and disadvantages.”

The report says that there is no strict dividing line between psychosis and normal experience: “Some people find it useful to think of themselves as having an illness. Others prefer to think of their problems as, for example, an aspect of their personality which sometimes gets them into trouble but which they would not want to be without.”

The report adds that antipsychotic medications are sometimes helpful, but that “there is no evidence that it corrects an underlying biological abnormality.” It then warns about the risk of taking these drugs for years.

And the report says that it is “vital” that those who suffer with distressing symptoms be given an opportunity to “talk in detail about their experiences and to make sense of what has happened to them” — and points out that mental health services rarely make such opportunities available.

This is a radically different vision of severe mental illness from the one held by most Americans, and indeed many American psychiatrists. Americans think of schizophrenia as a brain disorder that can be treated only with medication. Yet there is plenty of scientific evidence for the report’s claims.

Moreover, the perspective is surprisingly consonant — in some ways — with the new approach by our own National Institute of Mental Health, which funds much of the research on mental illness in this country. For decades, American psychiatric science took diagnosis to be fundamental. These categories — depression, schizophrenia, post-traumatic stress disorder — were assumed to represent biologically distinct diseases, and the goal of the research was to figure out the biology of the disease.

That didn’t pan out. In 2013, the institute’s director, Thomas R. Insel, announced that psychiatric science had failed to find unique biological mechanisms associated with specific diagnoses. What genetic underpinnings or neural circuits they had identified were mostly common across diagnostic groups. Diagnoses were neither particularly useful nor accurate for understanding the brain, and would no longer be used to guide research.

And so the institute has begun one of the most interesting and radical experiments in scientific research in years. It jettisoned a decades-long tradition of diagnosis-driven research, in which a scientist became, for example, a schizophrenia researcher. Under a program called Research Domain Criteria, all research must begin from a matrix of neuroscientific structures (genes, cells, circuits) that cut across behavioral, cognitive and social domains (acute fear, loss, arousal). To use an example from the program’s website, psychiatric researchers will no longer study people with anxiety; they will study fear circuitry.

Our current diagnostic system — the main achievement of the biomedical revolution in psychiatry — drew a sharp, clear line between those who were sick and those who were well, and that line was determined by science. The system started with the behavior of persons, and sorted them into types. That approach sank deep roots into our culture, possibly because sorting ourselves into different kinds of people comes naturally to us.

The institute is rejecting this system because it does not lead to useful research. It is starting afresh, with a focus on how the brain and its trillions of synaptic connections work. The British Psychological Society rejects the centrality of diagnosis for seemingly quite different reasons — among them, because defining people by a devastating label may not help them.

Both approaches recognize that mental illnesses are complex individual responses — less like hypothyroidism, in which you fall ill because your body does not secrete enough thyroid hormone, and more like metabolic syndrome, in which a collection of unrelated risk factors (high blood pressure, body fat around the waist) increases your chance of heart disease.

The implications are that social experience plays a significant role in who becomes mentally ill, when they fall ill and how their illness unfolds. We should view illness as caused not only by brain deficits but also by abuse, deprivation and inequality, which alter the way brains behave. Illness thus requires social interventions, not just pharmacological ones.

ONE outcome of this rethinking could be that talk therapy will regain some of the importance it lost when the new diagnostic system was young. And we know how to do talk therapy. That doesn’t rule out medication: while there may be problems with the long-term use of antipsychotics, many people find them useful when their symptoms are severe.

The rethinking comes at a time of disconcerting awareness that mental health problems are far more pervasive than we might have imagined. The World Health Organization estimates that one in four people will have an episode of mental illness in their lifetime. Mental and behavioral problems are the biggest single cause of disability on the planet. But in low- and middle-income countries, about four of five of those disabled by the illnesses do not receive treatment for them.

How to make dalgona coffee? What is my location right now? Tips on how to style verse in html css? What does transgender mean? How to clean computer monitor? What does polar mean in biology? What is the meaning of the buddha? How do i do tricks in potty racers? What are titers? What does rsi mean in stocks? when did tuna helper come out Aesop rock but it wont be there when your beard tips? How to apply eyelashes? What wrist does woman wear watch? Why is my polyester brush tips breaking wooster? What is a high blood pressure? What is the meaning of wonders? What does enable mean? What does gravy train meaning? How does david blain do those tricks? What does ons mean? What are beef tips made from? Tricks to wake up when alarm goes off? How to do a 3 way call on iphone? How to get rid of hemorrhoids? What does andante mean? how to remove video download helper from firefox What is the meaning of the word clarity? What does the name shane mean? Rocket league tips and tricks on how to get all the achievements xbox 1? How to pass college tips reddit? Tips on how to move chils to a toddler bed feom crib? Tricks to stop your eyes burning when cutting onion? What does rhapsody mean? What is fomo mean? What does sheer mean? What does reference range not detected mean? Tips on how to be better at debating? Why does our mind play tricks on us when we look at optical illusions? What is frizzy hair meaning? How to deal with constipation? How to measure a penis? Guitat tricks how to change password? What does the teal ribbon mean? how to uninstall video download helper extension for chrome What does increment mean? Do your eyes play tricks on you when tired? What is a sex offender? Tips for how much reverb for vocals? How to remove k tips? What are analytics? Which of the following abbreviations has more than one medical meaning? When in rome do as the romans do meaning? How to delete a microsoft account? What cut of meat to use for beef tips and gravy? How do i add tips on the clover pos? What does lmgafpsdwalst meaning? Mean tricks mad home sellers when leaving their home? What does cataracts look like? What does a high kappa value mean? How to measure finger for ring size? Tips on how to make sugar dissolve in frosting? What does how's tricks? mean? What does nerfed mean? wii u usb helper how to steam web helper how to close multiple What does it mean when the battery light comes on? What does flesh mean? Which of the following tips on how to speak more professionally is accurate? What does a high inr mean? How to connect to itunes? What are the lvling tricks for elixer or rapid mind? What does ffs mean? Safety tips when cooking chicken? How to get a work permit? What do different color bullet tips mean? What does attract mean? What does annexation mean? Tips on how to win the lottery in south africa? What does sos mean in a car? How to wash makeup brushes? how to install air bag helper springs why is the beef pasta sauce taking a while to dissolve in my hamberger helper? How to remove anc with fake tips? What is the meaning of a libra? What is the meaning of immanuel? What day does doordash pay? How to make an ice cream cake? How to rollerblade tricks? What does gts? Charcoal grill chicken breast guide tips how step? Why can't i meaning? What are worry stones? How to buy series i bonds? How to remove quickbooks desktop export tips? What time are disney fireworks? What size tips go on tfv12? what is groove gfs browser helper ad on What is the meaning of molech in the bible? What are bullets with red tips? What does crop dust mean on tiktok? How to remove ear wax without q-tips? What are some tricks you can do when you know where their card is? What is a similarity between connotative meaning and figurative language? What is the meaning of moratorium? What does not selected mean on indeed? What does modulate mean? what does absolute cd4 helper mean What does a cyst look like? why does steam web helper use so much ram How to get rid of hemorrhoids fast? What is the meaning of the word meme? What does baffled mean? What does it mean to be a scorpio? How long does it take to withdraw money from robinhood? How to hack wifi? Tricks to shooting when you're cross eye dominant? What does promiscuous mean? What are the most popular candies? What is the spiritual meaning of jordan? What does a circle with a line through it mean? How do i record tips in payroll for employees in ca? How to make money at 13? How to reverse image search on phone? where to install trade skill master app helper what is the role of helper t cells and cytotoxic t cells What does hiya mean? How to get rid of lower back fat? How to grow a mustache? What does contingent house mean? How to check for bed bugs? What does freedom of press mean? Bologna children’s competition mail artworks envelope tips how to mail? What does russia invading ukraine mean for us? How to kick a soccer ball? What does mbn? How to get rid of keloid on nose? What does pulling tricks mean? Tips on when to kiss after a date? What is the meaning of sumer? How to kill a tick? How to slow down a video on iphone? How to speak to someone at irs? How do i connect my phone to my tv? Photosynth how to tips and tricks? What is the meaning of prize? What does burrito mean in spanish? What is the true meaning of ramadan? how to get rid of google chrome helper on activity monitor What does igg mean? How to spell? What is the meaning of wala? How to makemask? How to get a google phone number? What is resting heart rate? How to trademark a business name? How to calculate equity? How to look up tricks and john's? How to make forest in little alchemy? What is the meaning behind the song blue on black? What does high iron mean? Spider man miles morales how to do tricks? What is the meaning of statue of liberty? Tricks how to change font style in whatsapp chat? Tips how to win powerball? What does sa mean? how to play wii games on wii u usb helper How to like a text? How to get coffee stains out? How to transfer money from bank to bank? How to use excel? When can i teach my puppy tricks? how to stop web helper sound How to polish pitted stainless steel exhaust tips? How to put on a boutonniere? how to use linkedin helper What does bpa mean? what does java plug-in ssv helper do What is the meaning of the tree of life symbol? What is a valkyrie? Tips on how to miantane a hard erection? What time does hollywood studios open? How much is sns with tips? What does mph mean? What nfl football games are on today? How to connect ps4 controller to pc? Nintendo wii super mario bros tricks how to play? What does asinine mean? What does centric mean? What is oenophiles meaning? What does gtg mean in texting? What is the biblical meaning of fire in a dream? How to tie a necktie? Tips when living alone? What are plant cell walls made of? What is a scrotum? What does flabbergasted mean? What is the meaning of international women's day? How much does it cost to get tips on your nails? What is lgtm meaning? How to cook squash? Where it all began meaning? How to cross stitch? Why does my aloe vera have brown tips? What does gram mean? How to cook salmon on stove? What is the meaning of afloat? What is the meaning of thanksgiving in the bible? How to cook ribs on the grill? How long does it take a fridge to get cold? How to stop picking my fingers and moisturize my finger tips? How to treat covid 19? How to change instagram password? How to rot a tree stump fast? How to make oatmeal cookies? explain how helper t cells and b cells work to eliminate antigens What time s use speed up tricks on mx player? What fixes are mandatory after a home inspection? How many calories should i eat to gain weight? Why are chives drying out at tips? What the meaning of held in waec result? What are bowling balls made of? How to use a rice cooker? What are dermal fillers? What is the meaning of art of war? where to buy helper bot shoppe keep What no fly zone meaning? What is the meaning of bernie sanders meme? How to cook sausage links? What do upside down pineapples mean? What does the name karana mean? What is meaning of 420 friendly? How to become a social worker? What does it mean when your ear rings? How to know if an egg is bad? What is mean corpuscular hemoglobin? What does working remotely mean? How to make birria? What is a throat contusion? Who pay social security tax on tips? What does crv mean? What size is smok drip tips? Tips and tricks when operate extruder machine? How far we've come meaning? How to hack clash of clans? What does 1111 mean in the bible? What is a voyeur? What is the meaning of ellie? What is lasership? What does fond mean? What is first fruit offering meaning? How long does it take to get a master's degree? What does soc mean? How to keep strawberries fresh? How to plop hair? What is the meaning behind the movie master? What is the meaning of object in java? Do you pay taxes on tips when you drive for uber? What tricks can i use to flatten my lawn without having to have it rolled? Why would a group of preoperational children find magic tricks uninteres? What does cancer breath smell like? how to use the webmatrix chart helper How to get better in light jig irish tips? What is the meaning of recuperate? What is the meaning of push and pull? How to kill mosquitoes?