Criminals with personality Disorders
Open access
Abstract
Personality disorder is associated with self-harm and suicide, as well as criminal offending and violence towards others. These behaviours overlap when the means chosen to self-harm or attempt suicide put others at risk. In such circumstances, an individual's mental state at one and the same time may be deemed to meet the conditions for criminal responsibility, and to warrant involuntary hospital admission. I explore this tension in how people with personality disorder are treated at the hands of the criminal and civil law respectively in England and Wales: they may be deemed sufficiently mentally well to be punished for their crimes, but not deemed sufficiently mentally well to retain the right to make their own decisions about matters of serious importance to their own lives, including whether or not to continue them. The article divides into four sections. After introducing this tension, Section 2 sketches the nature of personality disorder and the psychology underlying self-directed and other-directed violence. Section 3 addresses the questions of whether people with personality disorder who are violent, whether towards self or others, typically meet the conditions for criminal responsibility and mental capacity respectively, considering in particular whether their underlying desires and values, or their emotional distress, affect their mental capacity to make treatment decisions. Section 4 then considers what we might do to address the tension, within the confines of current legislation. Drawing on The Review of the Mental Health Act 1983, I argue that we are ethically justified in involuntarily admitting to hospital people with personality disorder who pose a serious risk to themselves only if we simultaneously undertake to offer genuine help for their future, in the form of appropriate treatment, social support, and better life opportunities — a provision which, as things stand in England and Wales, is sorely lacking.
Keywords
Autonomy
Criminal responsibility
Mental capacity
my 600 lb life success stories quote about success ralph waldo emerson success poem secret to my success secret to success sleep for success pillow success academy charter schools success factors wellstar success kid now success mindset motivational quotes success positive affirmations success spelling success story the key to success the smell of success vaccine success rate weight loss success what is the success rate of proton therapy what is the success rate of radiation therapy what led to henry ford's success as an entrepreneur 16/8 intermittent fasting success stories best days to take for success career success high school connect for success fedex lake success how to spell success keto success stories national society of leadership and success reviews pfizer success rate positive affirmations for success purdue success factors login reading for success sanford success center secret of my success soundtrack success academy union square success breeds success success in high school success is not final failure is not fatal success is not final quote success vision conway ar success winston churchill quotes the road to success there is no elevator to success unconventional success what is success whole food success factors workman success systems dua for success dua for success hair transplant success rate how to measure success ivf success rates by age and number of embryos ladder of success lexapro success stories lung transplant success rate mirtazapine success stories outliers: the story of success ovidrel trigger shot success rate pcos pregnancy success rate positive affirmations success prayer for success professional success sayings on success success academy middle schools success baby success ce success ed login success hunters success rice boil in bag team success the national society of leadership and success reddit will success spoil rock hunter? 600 lb life success stories bone marrow transplant success rate breastfeeding success bumble success stories carpal tunnel surgery success rate conjoined triangles of success continuing success coq10 fertility success crystal for success dress for success chicago ek success entrepeneur success stories equipped for reading success everyday success team fistula surgery success rate getting off lexapro success stories great success meme hair transplant success rate heart transplant success rate ivf success rates by age jmu student success center keno success lpr success stories massage envy lake success measuring success quotes microsoft customer success manager salary palmers skin success pgs normal embryo success rate pillars of success podcast success pyramid of success quotes for success woman road to success seven spiritual laws of success spell success success factor wellstar success in french success is not final failure is not fatal success positive motivational quotes success poster success rates of ivf success winston churchill quotes success word the 7 spiritual laws of success the five rules of success trump has created 515 businesses and only 11 of them failed. that's a 98.64% success rate. weight loss success stories 2020 wellstar success factors what is a customer success manager what principles contribute to personal and professional success why is effective communication important to career success wishing you success 5 dpo symptoms success stories 600 lb life success stories achieve success african american quotes about success best success books castor oil at 37 weeks success celebrate success quote center for success and independence failure to success famous quotes about success gerson therapy success rate gerson therapy success rate gum graft success rate in vitro fertilization success rate la fitness lake success laser treatment for toenail fungus success rate 2020 leapfrog leapstart preschool success measure success quotes motivational quotes for students success opdivo and yervoy success stories pain pump success rate pictures of success quote about success quotes about success secret to success success academy uniform success academy union square success com success gif success in chinese success is not final success kid now success mindset success pictures success spell success virtual learning center the best revenge is massive success was d day a success weight loss success stories what is the success rate of heart valve replacement surgery which of the following groups have had notable political success by litigating in federal courts? words that mean success books about success center for academic success fenbendazole cancer success stories how i raised myself from failure to success in selling morning affirmations for success nextgen success community pathways to success was the new deal a success or failure 5aa embryo success rate aes success login carpal tunnel surgery success rate cone biopsy success rate driving to success
